This Literacy Life: compare and contrast

Showing posts with label compare and contrast. Show all posts
Showing posts with label compare and contrast. Show all posts

The Magic of Fairy Tales Part 2

Last week, I wrote about the lessons our students can learn from fairy tales. You can check that out in this blog post ~ The Magic of Fairy Tales.  This week I am focusing on how we can use them for instruction in our classrooms.
Fairy tales are great for helping with various comprehension strategies. The simplicity of them helps readers understand some tricky skills.

When teaching a new comprehension skill, many times I use fairy tales since they are a familiar story to many children. We don't have to take the time to think about the plot of the story and can focus on that skill.

For example, The Three Little Pigs is a familiar story to many students. I use this one a lot to help older students simply understand something like cause and effect or theme. I really like using it to help introduce QAR (Question-Answer Relationship) to students. I created a QAR sort using this story to help students with this skill. Click below to head to my TPT store to purchase it. I hope to add some more fairy tales to this over the summer, if time will allow me.
QAR Sort Based on The Three Little Pigs

I love that fairy tales are such simple stories. They are perfect for teaching plot structure, even to older students. Since the stories are familiar (sometimes), they can really hone in on those parts of the plot. Here is an example of how a group of 6th graders used Little Red Riding Hood to show plot structure.
Fairy tales are great for helping with various comprehension strategies. The simplicity of them helps readers understand some tricky skills.

The rich vocabulary in the tales also allows for great context clues and vocabulary instruction. Kids can get so much out of those tales.  Reading this excerpt alone from Rapunzel, you can see all of the great vocabulary students can learn.
Fairy tales are great for helping with various comprehension strategies. The simplicity of them helps readers understand some tricky skills.

And let's not forget comparing and contrasting. Not only can students compare and contrast characters within the fairy tales, but they can compare characters between tales or even types of tales. I spent that summer in graduate school looking at some different versions of Cinderella, and now there are so many others for different tales. I love seeing how different cultures change the tales up a little to meet their needs. Recently, I purchased Petite Rouge by Mike Artell, which is a Cajun version of Little Red Riding Hood. I love reading those with students and then comparing and contrasting the two books ~ characters and all!

A few years ago, I worked with my students to see the differences between Goldilocks and the Three Bears and  The Three Snow Bears by Jan Brett. Here is what we did to see the differences.
Fairy tales are great for helping with various comprehension strategies. The simplicity of them helps readers understand some tricky skills.
Click {here} to see that blog post!

So, use those fairy tales in every grade level! Our students can learn so much from them!

Share it with the world and pin for later!
Fairy tales are great for helping with various comprehension strategies. The simplicity of them helps readers understand some tricky skills.

0

Growing Readers and Writers by Teaching with Mentor Texts

I am so excited to join my friends at The Reading Crew for another fun Mentor Text Linky Hop. 25 of us have gotten together to bring you many different books and lessons to enhance literacy instruction.



This time of year many different animals are all around, and children LOVE to read and learn about different animals. A few months ago, Scholastic had a set of Who Would Win books, and I knew my students would not be able to put them down.


I chose these books to use for several different reasons. My biggest reason was engagement. Kids love these books, and I wish you could have all seen how their faces lit up when I took them out.  They loved that they could choose their own books too. The books include facts about two different animals or insects that are similar in some ways yet different in others. The book compares and contrasts them beautifully with many pictures and text features. At the end, Pallotta pits the two animals against each other and tells who he thinks would win and how.  How fun!




We spent some time talking about comparing and contrasting regular items and pictures. I then allowed the students to choose a book from my selection to read. They read the book, all the while discussing their own books. I let the conversations roll because I knew the reading was authentic!

After reading the book, each student filled out the chart, showing how the two creatures were alike and different. Each opposite square had to match {has a stinger---uses teeth}. This was a challenge, but they finally caught on after a few attempts.




The best part about these books is that the other creature could win. In my pack is a page where students can focus on certain parts of the creatures to write how the other creature would win. Here are some examples of my students' work.



Students could also research two different animals and write their own "Who Would Win" type of essay.

You can grab my Who Would Win activities by clicking here or on the picture below:




3

Back to School Book Talk Thursday

 I can't believe I have already returned to work!  Next week our kids come back, and I think I am ready.  Here's to another edition of Book Talk Thursday.

This week I am focusing on two fun back to school back to school books.  Clifford and Curious George are both familiar characters to many adults and children.  These two back to school books are perfect for young children.

Everyone loves Clifford!  Clifford's First School Day tells the story of Clifford the puppy as he goes to school with Emily Elizabeth.  Of course, he gets into some trouble, but the class always finds a way to make Clifford have an awesome day.


Another favorite is Curious George.  In Curious George's First Day of School, he goes to school to be Mr. Apple's special helper.  While there, he gets into the paints and makes a big mess.  Of course, he works to clean everything up but continues to make an even bigger mess.  The children also help him get everything back in order.

Children will not only love both Clifford and Curious George, but they will enjoy comparing and contrasting the two characters.  I definitely plan to use these books with some of my groups as we go back to school next week. It will be easy to create a bubble map (or Venn Diagram) to show how the two stories are alike and different, such an important skill for many children.

So, if you are still enjoying your summer, have fun! For those of you returning to school, have a marvelous year!  I am excited to get a new start for 2015-2016!

Don't forget to link up!




   

    An InLinkz Link-up
   


1